Hepper blog

Search our database of over 9,984 posts with up-to-date information from our experts and veterinarians.

Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

PupBox vs. BarkBox Subscriptions: Which Is Best for You & Your Pup?

By Nicole Cosgrove
Share
Ask us a question in the comments
pupbox vs barkbox review

Despite our desire to spoil our doggies with niceties, life can get in the way of finding the time to shop for toys and treats on a consistent basis. One of the best ways of circumventing this is by signing up for a monthly subscription box that caters to dogs.

Dog subscription boxes are service providers who send dogs a box of goodies each month. This saves the owner the hassle of regular visits to the pet store to look for treats and toys for your pet. Additionally, reputable subscription box companies do not compromise on quality, ensuring that your doggo receives only the best.

Another advantage of using subscription box services is that they offer variety. They switch up the treats and toys in your dog’s goodie bag regularly to allow them to enjoy new things consistently.

Among subscription box services, PupBox and BarkBox are arguably the most popular companies. However, they cater to different sets of dog owners. For example, PupBox caters to new puppy owners. As such, their box typically consists of toys, treats, training guides, chews, and basic accessories.

On the other hand, BarkBox caters to dogs of all sizes. This company’s calling card is its ability to customize boxes for individual dogs. It is a great option for people who love variety.

To allow you to make an informed decision, here's everything you need to know about PupBox and BarkBox.

At a Glance

Let’s look at the key points of each product.

PupBox

  • Toys
  • Treats
  • Chews
  • Accessories
  • Training products

BarkBox

  • Toys
  • Treats
  • Chews
  • Customizable
  • Themed collections

Overview of PupBox

As mentioned, PupBox caters to puppies. As such, the contents in their box of goodies consist of handpicked products that suit the needs of puppies. These include treats, toys, and chews for your pup’s enjoyment. Additionally, the company throws in various accessories that will assist you in grooming and training your pup. The box also contains training guides and tips to help you become a better pet parent.

Another great thing about this subscription service is that they change your pup’s box as your pooch grows. This ensures that the box is able to meet your pup’s needs even as they grow older.

Moreover, even though PupBox is designed to cater to puppies, they have an option that caters to adult dogs. In addition to toys and treats, the  PupBox’s adult box comes with training guides that allow you to teach advanced tricks to your dog.

Pros

  • Caters to pups
  • Great for new dog owners
  • Has option for adult dogs
  • High-quality products

Cons

  • Pricey

Overview of BarkBox

BarBox Frenchie
Image Credit: Barkbox

As mentioned, BarkBox is designed to cater to all types of dogs. The typical box consists of 2 toys, 2 all-natural treats, and a chew. The best thing about BarkBox is that their toys are created in-house to ensure superior quality, which is something you won’t get with most other subscription services.

One unique aspect about BarkBox is that they have a theme for every month. This means that the box’s contents will change every month based on the theme the company is after. The benefit of this strategy is that your dog will never get bored of their treats and toys as they keep changing. As you can imagine, dogs on this subscription service are always looking forward to their monthly box.

Additionally, BarkBox allows you to customize your pooch’s box to suit their needs. For example, you can specify what the company should avoid when it comes to ingredients or toy features. You can also change product assortment to increase or decrease the various products that come in the box. This will allow you to receive boxes that you feel suit your doggo the most.

What’s more, BarkBox has various packages to allow for even further customization. These packages include the standard BarkBox subscription and the Super Chewer Box. The latter comes with durable chew toys to cater to dogs with a high bite force.

The best thing about BarkBox is that they donate 10% of their profits to various shelters and rescues.

Pros

  • Highly diverse
  • Allows for customization
  • Cater to dogs of all ages
  • High-quality products
  • Gives back to society
  • Excellent customer service
  • Price friendly

Cons

  • Renews subscription automatically

PupBox vs. BarkBox: What Are the differences?

As mentioned, the main difference between these two subscription box services is who they cater to. Their individual products also differ considerably. Let us take a closer look.

Toys

Edge: BarkBox

Unlike BarkBox, PupBox does not manufacture its toys in-house. As a result, their products tend to vary considerably in terms of quality. Nonetheless, the company goes out of its way to source its products from reputable manufacturers. Additionally, they have an in-house testing team.

Therefore, even though they do not make their own products, they do their best to ensure that the toys are safe for your pup.

BarkBox, on the other hand, designs all their toys. As such, you can be sure that the toys inside your box are of superior quality. Their toys are renowned for their durability.

Treats

Edge: Tie

Both companies source their treats from the USA or Canada, so you can expect high-quality standards. PupBox’s treats, however, are designed to facilitate a puppy’s development rather than being purely for reward purposes.

Price

Edge: BarkBox

The standard BarkBox package costs $35 per month, while a 6-month subscription costs $26 per box. PupBox, on the other hand, costs $39 per month, while a 6-month subscription costs $32 per box.

However, if you choose BarkBox’s SuperChewer package, you will have to part with $39 monthly or $32 per box for a 6-month subscription. As mentioned, the Superchewer package caters to powerful dogs that go through standard toys quickly. Therefore, even though this package is pricey, it is worth it.

What the Users Say

After going through numerous consumer reviews, here is the consensus: BarkBox has exceptional customer service, diverse product variety, and remarkably durable products. PupBox, on the other hand, has lackluster customer service. However, their products have been extremely helpful to new pup owners.

Conclusion

PupBox and BarkBox are the two most popular box subscription services today for good reason — they don't cut corners. Neither is superior to the other since they cater to different types of dogs. PupBox is the best subscription service for puppies, while BarkBox is the best service for adult dogs.


Featured Image Credit: Baramyou0708, Shutterstock

Get Hepper In Your Inbox

Pet care tips from our vets and experts, straight to your inbox.

List

Select all that apply.

You may opt-out at any time. View our Privacy Policy for more information.

Nicole Cosgrove
Authored by

Nicole Cosgrove

Join the conversation

Ask a question, share your story, or send private feedback.

Rate this post
Required to post. Only our editors see your rating.
Who should see this?

A human reviews every comment before it appears. Your email is never published.

Picked to go with this article

10 BarkBox Dog Box Subscription Alternatives in 2026: Our Comparisson

10 BarkBox Dog Box Subscription Alternatives in 2026: Our Comparisson

BarkBox is an industry leader that provides a monthly box of goodies for your favorite canine, but several competitors have popped up in recent years to challe…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·
BarkBox vs Chewy Goody Box for Dogs Comparison 2026: Pros, Cons & Verdict

BarkBox vs Chewy Goody Box for Dogs Comparison 2026: Pros, Cons & Verdict

Doggy-inspired boxes are growing in popularity. It's no wonder, as these combo packs allow you to pay a set fee to surprise your pup monthly. You will soon fil…

Ashley Bates
By Ashley Bates ·
What Comes in a BarkBox: 7 Common Items

What Comes in a BarkBox: 7 Common Items

BarkBox is a popular monthly subscription service that delivers various dog toys, treats, and other goodies to your doorstep. While the specific contents of ea…

Ed Malaker
By Ed Malaker ·
Bullymake vs. BarkBox 2026 Dog Subscription Box Comparison

Bullymake vs. BarkBox 2026 Dog Subscription Box Comparison

In the age of subscriptions, you can now also purchase subscription boxes for your canine! Both Bullymake and BarkBox provide subscription boxes full of toys a…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·

Keep reading

More stories you might like

Super Chewer Dog Subscription Box by BARK Review 2026: An Expert Guide

BARK is a subscription company that provides a month’s supply of dog toys and treats through creatively themed boxes. The Super Chewer box is a specially made…

Jessica Kim
By Jessica Kim ·
Super Chewer Dog Subscription Box by BARK Review 2026: An Expert Guide

Dog Gift Basket Guide & Ideas - Where to Buy Them?

Do you have a four-legged, furry good old boy or pretty girl in your life? Not all gift-giving needs to happen as an exchange between human beings. Our pets ar…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·
Dog Gift Basket Guide & Ideas - Where to Buy Them?

Bully Sticks vs. Rawhide: Which Is Best for Your Dog?

Bully sticks and rawhide are both familiar chew toys for dogs. However, there are a few significant differences between them. Selecting the right option for yo…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·
Bully Sticks vs. Rawhide: Which Is Best for Your Dog?

The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie: Which Fresh Dog Food Service is Best?

If you walk down the dog food aisle at your local grocery store or pet store and feel a bit overwhelmed by all the options, you’re not alone. As dog owners, we…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·
The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie: Which Fresh Dog Food Service is Best?

Progressive Retinal Atrophy in Dogs: Signs, Causes & Treatment

If you’re like most dog fanatics, the day you adopt a puppy or adult dog is one of your happiest, most exciting, and most emotional days. The last thing on you…

Gregory Iacono
By Gregory Iacono ·
Progressive Retinal Atrophy in Dogs: Signs, Causes & Treatment

Is Great Wolf Lodge Pet Friendly? 2026 Policy & Requirements

Are you planning a trip to one of the Great Wolf Lodge’s locations but unsure if they are pet-friendly? Knowing the facts before you go is essential in ensurin…

Rachel Giordano
By Rachel Giordano ·
Is Great Wolf Lodge Pet Friendly? 2026 Policy & Requirements

Is Meijer Pet Friendly? 2026 Policy, Requirements & FAQ

Have you ever considered taking your furry friend to your local Meijer store? If so, this guide will shed some light on Meijer’s pet policy for the current yea…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·
Is Meijer Pet Friendly? 2026 Policy, Requirements & FAQ