Hepper blog

Search our database of over 9,984 posts with up-to-date information from our experts and veterinarians.

Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Are Turtles Good Pets? Reason, Facts & FAQ

By Gregory Iacono
Share
Ask us a question in the comments
an eastern box turtle on a pathway

There's no denying that, as Americans, we love our pets. Millions of American households have at least one pet and many pets, from dogs and cats to rabbits, fish, guinea pigs, ferrets, and more. Among them is the turtle, which has become quite popular over the last few decades. The question is, are turtles good pets? The answer, at least according to the Humane Society of the United States, is no, and for several good reasons.

In the article below, we’ll shed light on the reasons for the Humane Society’s stance. We’ll also look at some of the reasons why turtles still might make good pets. It’s vital info that can help you make the best decision on whether to bring a turtle into your home.

Why Don’t Turtles Make Good Pets?

The Humane Society of the United States believes that turning a turtle into a pet is not a good idea. Yes, they are docile creatures, and some breeds are attractive and fun to watch. Besides that, however, turtles are not easy to care for, especially for first-time owners.

Turtles Can Make You Sick

As an adult, there's a very good chance you've heard of the food-borne illness salmonella caused by the salmonella bacteria. While most people get sick from eating food tainted by the bacteria, it’s also carried by reptiles, including turtles.

If the turtle you adopt has salmonella bacteria on their body, it could easily be transferred to you or other people in your family. The risk is so high that it's illegal in the United States to sell small turtles. The health risk they pose to children, senior citizens, and people with lowered resistance due to other health issues is simply too great.

Baby snapping turtle on hand
Image Credit: Hoth Cook, Shutterstock

The Salmonella Bacteria on Turtles Can Be Transferred to Others by Touch

Knowing the risk posed by salmonella bacteria is highest for children, you might think that, as an adult, it's okay to own a turtle. The problem is, if you touch your turtle or their tank and then touch someone else, you can transfer the bacteria to that person.

The journal Pediatrics performed a study in 2006 that found something very interesting and terrifying. Exposure to reptiles was a big cause of salmonella poisoning in infants. When you consider how unlikely it is to have an infant handle a turtle or other reptile, it's only logical that the Salmonella was transferred by someone else.

Turtles Are an Invasive Species

Many folks adopt a turtle or two, thinking they will make great pets. Unfortunately, when they realize they no longer want the animal, there are few options to re-home them. Rescue groups usually don’t take turtles as they’re overwhelmed by requests, which leads many people to let their pets loose into the wild.

What’s the problem with setting them free? First, it’s illegal to let a turtle loose in the wild. Second, your pet turtle might carry diseases that kill wild turtles or other animals. Then there’s the fact that some turtle species will eat the food local species eat, causing their decline. It’s become so bad that turtles are now on the list of the 100 most invasive species on the planet!

a read eared slider turtle at a national park
Image Credit: marie martin, Shutterstock

Turtles Can Live for Decades

Imagine if the dog you got as a child lived so long that, when you retired, they were still with you. That’s what can happen with a turtle, as these animals can live up to 30 years or longer in captivity. And when we say longer, we’re talking about 50, 60, and 70 years.

That’s an incredibly long time to be a caretaker for any pet, let alone one that can’t give you any genuine affection. Plus, your turtle won’t stay one size like a dog or cat but will continue to grow its entire life, forcing you to get ever-increasing tanks and other equipment for your pet.

You Can’t Adopt a Baby Turtle

If you think it would be nice to get a baby turtle for your child as a pet, think again. Not only do they pose a true health risk to your child due to salmonella, but selling turtles under 4 inches in length anywhere in the United States is illegal.

Turtles Need a Lot of Specialized Care

Many believe that turtles are “easy to care for,” but the reality is far from that. These animals need large tanks, for example, and specialized filtration systems similar to aquarium fish.

Turtles also need specialized lighting to make Vitamin D and prevent bone anomalies, and they require a lot of cleaning of their bodies and habitat. In short, turtles are more challenging to care for than most people believe they are.

red eared turtle in aquarium
Image Credit: Mark Leung, Shutterstock

What Factors Make a Turtle a Good Pet?

There’s no denying that a turtle is a fascinating animal. (If they weren’t, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles wouldn’t have been a worldwide phenomenon for the last 40 years!) Turtles have unique personalities and move slowly enough that kids can take a long look at them whenever they like.

Turtles also can teach kids about the world and what it means to put another creature’s life in your hands, figuratively speaking. Feeding a turtle can teach kids about nutrition and the responsibility it takes to care for an animal.

A turtle might be a good choice for an older child or an adult who wants a docile pet that doesn’t demand a high level of attention. You must, however, go into the situation with your eyes wide open to the downsides of turtle ownership.

Final Thoughts

Although they have some amazing attributes, keeping a turtle as a pet seems to have more negatives than positives. The worst of these negatives is the risk of salmonella poisoning, especially for small children and seniors.

Specialized care, the difficulty of re-homing an unwanted turtle, and the fact that they’re considered invasive don’t help, either. All these factors put together make turtles a poor choice of pet except for the most dedicated and diligent people. Therefore, most veterinarians recommend not adopting a turtle and instead opting for another species of pet.

See also:

Sources

Featured Image Credit: Simply Photos, Shutterstock

Get Hepper In Your Inbox

Pet care tips from our vets and experts, straight to your inbox.

List

Select all that apply.

You may opt-out at any time. View our Privacy Policy for more information.

Gregory Iacono
Authored by

Gregory Iacono

Join the conversation

Ask a question, share your story, or send private feedback.

Rate this post
Required to post. Only our editors see your rating.
Who should see this?

A human reviews every comment before it appears. Your email is never published.

Picked to go with this article

Turtles as Pets: 10 Vet-Approved Pros & Cons

Turtles as Pets: 10 Vet-Approved Pros & Cons

Should you get a pet turtle? If this is a question that you have, you should learn more about these reptiles before getting one as a pet. A lot of research sho…

Visnja Radosavljevic
By Visnja Radosavljevic ·
Are Tortoises Good Pets? Facts & FAQ

Are Tortoises Good Pets? Facts & FAQ

Do you often see a tortoise and have an urge to keep one as a pet? If so, it’s not your fault! These adorable little animals appear docile and shy but make ama…

Jeff Weishaupt
By Jeff Weishaupt ·
Can You Get Salmonella From Turtles? Vet-Approved Facts & FAQ

Can You Get Salmonella From Turtles? Vet-Approved Facts & FAQ

The reptile world is unique, with interesting animal species like lizards and turtles. These reptiles can be kept as pets, but they may pose a health risk to y…

Visnja Radosavljevic
By Visnja Radosavljevic ·
Do Turtles Bite People? What to Do if It Happens

Do Turtles Bite People? What to Do if It Happens

Many people keep exotic pets, perhaps because they’re unusual, even if they aren’t cuddly like a dog or cat. Roughly 6 million American households include at l…

Chris Dinesen Rogers
By Chris Dinesen Rogers ·

Keep reading

More stories you might like

Tortoise vs. Turtle: Differences & Comparison (With Pictures)

Are you considering getting a pet turtle or a pet tortoise? Do you know the difference between the two? When people mention turtles, they’re mainly referring t…

Visnja Radosavljevic
By Visnja Radosavljevic ·
Tortoise vs. Turtle: Differences & Comparison (With Pictures)

Do Turtles Like to Be Pet or Held? Vet-Approved Facts & Tips

Turtles are a mysterious bunch, so reading them is no easy feat. One thing turtle owners swear by, though, is that turtles do have personalities and display a…

Kit Copson
By Kit Copson ·
Do Turtles Like to Be Pet or Held? Vet-Approved Facts & Tips

Red-Eared Slider Turtle: Pictures, Facts, Diet & Care Guide

Reptiles like turtles might not be the first thing that comes to mind when you think of pets, but they can still provide a unique type of companionship. Not to…

Elizabeth Gray
By Elizabeth Gray ·
Red-Eared Slider Turtle: Pictures, Facts, Diet & Care Guide

How to Take Care of a Baby Turtle? 11 Essential Tips

Turtles aren't great pets for every family. While having a baby turtle or tortoise might sound awesome, these animals require special care, attention, and husb…

Chantelle Fowler
By Chantelle Fowler ·
How to Take Care of a Baby Turtle? 11 Essential Tips

How Long Do Turtles Live? Average Lifespan, Data & Care

As you embark on the rewarding journey of pet ownership, considering a turtle may bring an interesting twist. Famous for their long lifespans, turtles can prov…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·
How Long Do Turtles Live? Average Lifespan, Data & Care

Are Turtles Social Animals? Group Dynamic & Behavior Explored

Have you ever wondered if turtles are social animals? Do they enjoy the company of others or prefer a more solitary lifestyle? Well, get ready to discover the…

Nicole Cosgrove
By Nicole Cosgrove ·
Are Turtles Social Animals? Group Dynamic & Behavior Explored

10 Types of Turtles That Are Kept as Pets (With Info & Pictures)

Turtles can make interesting and unique pets, particularly compared to dogs and cats. They are fairly undemanding, can be fascinating to watch, and make wonder…

Kathryn Copeland
By Kathryn Copeland ·
10 Types of Turtles That Are Kept as Pets (With Info & Pictures)

Can Frogs and Turtles Live Together? Risks & Considerations

Housing frogs and turtles can take up a lot of space, and their enclosures need to be large enough to provide your pets with ample space. Sometimes, it can fee…

Jordyn Alger
By Jordyn Alger ·
Can Frogs and Turtles Live Together? Risks & Considerations